For starters, go non-homogenized. Most farmers market milks are non-homogenized, but my supermarket usually carries a few cartons, as well. These milks are filled with nice, big dairy-fat globules that rise up to the top for a recognizable cream line at the the neck of the bottle. Homogenized milk, on the other hand, has been processed by a high-pressure pump that breaks those blobby fats into smaller bits, increasing their surface area by up to ten times. When this happens, "the milk proteins migrate and stabilize around those new fat globules," explainsDr. Lloyd Metzger, of South Dakota State University's Dairy Science department. The distribution of fat and protein changes so drastically in this process that homogenized milks are virtually impossible to make into viable mozzarella.
Once you have the right milk, though, the process is surprisingly easy and fun. In fact, it's almost as satisfying as throwing Mentos in a bottle of soda and watching it explode. No, there won't be geysers of milk spouting in your kitchen, but fresh cheeses happen really quickly, which means you'll go from a pot of milk to curds and whey in a matter of minutes, and from curds and whey to a ball of mozzarella in just a handful more. I'm talking under an hour, start to finish, especially once you get the hang of things.
Here's a quick overview of how it's gonna go.
- Coagulate the milk into curds:
- Drain and slice the curds:
- Spin the curds:
- Resting the cheese:
We'll begin by adding citric acid to the milk, gradually heat it, and then add rennet to complete the coagulation process, at which point we'll be left with curds (destined to become our cheese) and whey (the watery byproduct that's left behind).
Once the curds have separated from the whey, we'll drain them of extra liquid and slice them.
A relatively brief process of manipulating the curds under high heat, either in the microwave or in heated whey, "spinning" them until they're shiny, smooth, and ready to be formed into balls.
We'll let the cheese relax in room temperature whey for roughly 20 minutes before we dig in.
WHAT YOU'LL NEED
Unless you're the kind of person who keeps a pantry stocked with specialized cheese-making equipment, you're going to have to do a little shopping before you can get started. For starters, do a quick inventory and make sure you have a full set of measuring spoons and a liquid measuring cup—we'll be adding very precise amounts of those coagulants. One of the most crucial items you should have is an accurate instant-read thermometer, like the Thermapen, to ensure that you keep the milk within its ideal temperature range throughout the entire process. You'll also need a fine-mesh strainer, a heat-resistant bowl (pyrex or stainless steel are both fine), a slotted spoon, and a large, thick-bottomed stainless steel pot.
As for the actual ingredients? I'm happy to report that your milk will probably be the most expensive item you have to purchase. Food-grade citric acid is available in most well-stocked supermarkets, often near canning-related items, but if you can't find it, just order it online instead; my one-pound supply cost about $10 and it'll last me a long, long time (each batch of mozzarella only calls for a couple of teaspoons).
Rennet may be a trickier supermarket find, but it's an easy online order, provided you don't get confused by all the options. Rennet is sold in both tablet and liquid forms, and you'll find animal and vegetable options for each. But frankly, all are equally effective and conversion is straightforward (more on that in the recipe). That said, I prefer to buy liquid rennet since it's easier to measure if I choose to scale the recipe up or down; here's the one I use—another $10 ingredient that'll yield dozens of batches.
Finally, you'll need pair or two of gloves. We'll be sticking our hands into some very hot water during the spinning stage and, while some professionals may go in bareback, I'm not nearly so bold. I typically wear a couple pairs of latex gloves layered on top of each other, but one (or even two) pairs of heavy-duty dish gloves will also do the trick, especially if your hands are sensitive to heat. Just make sure the gloves are clean, fit your hands snugly, and don't have any holes in them (I learned that one the hard way).
STEP 1. CURDS AND WHEY
This stage all happens in your stainless steel pot. There's no need to throw on your gloves just yet, but you do want your slotted spoon and your thermometer handy. We'll start by pouring the milk into the pot, whisking it well to distribute the cream and butterfat, and then adding the citric acid.
Many recipes call for diluting the citric acid in water before adding it to the milk, but I haven't been able to find a compelling reason to dirty the measuring cup or dilute the milk—sprinkling the citric acid in and giving the milk a good stir works every time. Just make sure to stir for at least 15 to 30 seconds to ensure that the acid fully dissolves and isn't just sitting on the bottom of the pot.
Then, turn the heat on to medium-low and continue to stir the pot regularly—we definitely don't want the bottom to scald. As the temperature rises, you'll start to see tiny little clumps of curd starting to form, perhaps as early as 70 or 75°F. Meanwhile, dilute the rennet in water; unlike citric acid, rennet is so powerful and fast-acting that dilution is the best way to ensure it mixes into the milk evenly before coagulation freezes everything in place.
When the milk reaches 88 to 90°F, add the rennet and stir well until it's evenly combined with the milk, about 30 more seconds.
The traditional curd-cutting step.
Now, here's where things get interesting. Most recipes suggest that you turn the heat off once the curds hit that 88 to 90°F mark, cover the pot, and allow the curds to solidify for anywhere from five minutes up to several hours. In this more traditional method, you'd check to make sure the curds can form a clean break by seeing if they pull away from the whey (you can see an example in the top left image above). Then, you'd slice your curds into a one-inch grid and continue heating the pot until the whey reaches 105°F before straining the curds.
This slicing step is a fundamental one in most cheese-making situations: the size at which the curd is cut and the amount it is heated determines how much whey it expels, which has a profound impact on the final cheese.
But ever impatient, I decided to try breaking the rules and compare the traditional method to something a little more straightforward. Rather than turn off the heat (and add a minimum of 10 to 15 minutes to the recipe), I simply continued to heat the milk over low heat after adding the rennet, stirring very occasionally, until the whey hit that 105°F mark. That infrequent stirring actually breaks the curd up slightly, not unlike the traditional cutting step.
For both batches, I used a slotted spoon to scoop the curds out of the pot and into a mesh strainer set over a bowl (more on that in a moment), and made them into mozzarella. When they were ready, I asked my colleagues to blind taste the two mozzarellas side-by-side, one made using the more classic curd-cutting method and the other from my shortcut approach. Not only were the results virtually indistinguishable from each other, but the final yield of cheese was the same. Less effort, less time, and identical results? It's basically a no-brainer to take the easier route.
STEP 2: DRAIN AND PORTION THE CURDS
Once your whey has reached 105°F, turn off the stove and let the pot stand for five to 10 minutes—we want to give the curds and whey the opportunity to settle and separate from each other. Then, use the slotted spoon to carefully ladle the curds into the strainer, pressing down gently to drain off extra whey between spoonfuls. You can tip the strainer from side to side, as in the image above, to help drain extra liquid off the top, since the curds should naturally form a large, semi-solid mass. If you feel like there are a lot of small pieces still floating in the whey, you can send it through a separate strainer, but don't pour it down the drain! We'll need it again in a minute. Once you've let the curds drain and cool for roughly 10 minutes, you can place the mass on a cutting board and slice them into one-inch cubes, like so:
If your curds have more of a crumbly ricotta-like texture and resist forming a single mass, you're looking at a milk issue. Time to get on the phone with your dairy and find out what the pasteurization story is.
STEP 3: SPINNING
Assuming you're looking at shiny cubes of curd, you're halfway there! Now's when I like to add some salt to the mix. Great mozzarella shouldn't be noticeably salty, but I do like to offset the intense milky sweetness just a bit. Go ahead and season the whey that's still in your pot with one tablespoon of kosher salt (you can add more to taste if you want, or feel free to skip the salt altogether), stir it well, and then pour one third of the whey into a bowl and set it aside. We'll be using this bowl of room-temperature whey for resting our mozzarella down the line.
From here on out, there are two ways to proceed. The first method involves the microwave, which, I'm pleasantly surprised to admit, totally does work and yields almost-as-delicious results. If you decide to use the microwave, you can put about a third of your curds into a microwave-safe dish, microwave it on high for 15 seconds, and just skip the instructions in the next paragraph.
The second method is the one I'm more partial to, since I find that it lends a bit more control to the process and gives you slightly more tender mozzarella, all without a whole lot more work. For this approach, you can place the pot containing the remaining two-thirds of your whey over high heat and raise the temperature to around 180°F (though even hotter is fine). Meanwhile, place about one-third of the curds in a heat-safe bowl. When the whey's hot, throw on your gloves and use a ladle to add enough liquid to cover the curds. You can keep the pot on low heat; you'll need more hot whey in a bit.
Whether you're using the microwave or the whey, after about 15 seconds, stick your heavily begloved finger into the dish. Can you handle the heat? If it's intolerable, grab a spoon to fish the curds out; otherwise, use your hand to gently draw them together and lift them out. They should be very soft and kind of sticky. If they're practically liquid-soft, leave them be for a minute or two. Have a sip of beer, check your email, sneak some bites of the cold curd resting on your countertop. Then stick your hands back in and grab the curds.
Do not knead the curds. There are many, many recipes that tell you to treat the curds "like bread dough." Only do this if you'd like to make cheese with the texture of squeaky chewing gum; otherwise, simply lift the mass out of the whey with both hands and slowly draw them apart. There shouldn't be a sensation of forcibly stretching, pulling, kneading, or tearing the curd; rather, the curd should literally stretch itself. If the curd resists, return it to the bowl and add some more hot whey (or stick the bowl back in the microwave), and try again. If the curd just continues to break and tear, you are probably looking at a milk issue. Here's what bad curd, made from pasteurized homogenized milk, looks like in action:
Bad curd from start to finish.
The curd above won't make an enjoyable mozzarella. Believe me, I've tried. You can manipulate it into something that looks just like mozzarella, but it won't taste like it one bit. You can try to salvage it by blending it into a spread with some seasonings like salt, pepper, and herbs, or just pick at it. It's kind of a tasty snack...it's just not the tasty snack you meant to make.
Assuming all is going well, simply fold the stretched curd back on itself after each pull, dipping the bundle back into hot whey as necessary to keep it pliable. You only want to "spin" the curds until they are shiny. When I'm working with high-quality milk, this can happen after just two, maybe four long stretches. If it's still looking dull after three or four stretches, try adding more hot whey from the stovetop—your issue may be temperature-related.
Once the whole mass looks smooth and shiny, fold the stretched curd over itself until it's roughly the size of your palm. With your other hand, make a C-shape with your forefinger and thumb, and then push the curd through that space, exerting pressure with your fingers to shape it into a sphere. Try to press hard enough to prevent any bubbles from forming under the skin (though a few small ones here and there are inevitable, especially when you're first starting out). Alternatively, you can make a full loop with your thumb and forefinger to make bocconcini—the small, egg-size mozzarella balls are little more manageable for beginners. In either case, when you have a ball you're happy with, pinch off any remaining curd. You just made mozzarella. Do a little dance and then resist the temptation to pop it right into your mouth.
STEP 4: RESTING
Gently lower the ball into the bowl of room-temperature whey that you set aside earlier, and continue spinning your remaining curd. If you've opted to use the whey for something else, or accidentally threw it away, you can use room-temperature water, salted to taste, as a resting liquid instead. Do not use ice water, though it's a common recommendation in mozzarella recipes. It will leave you with a rubbery ball devoid of all flavor. Just take a look at the samples below:
From left: mozzarella left to sit out after shaping; mozzarella rested in room-temp whey; mozzarella rested in room-temp water; and mozzarella rested in ice water.
The cheese all the way to the left was placed directly on a cutting board, where it proceeded to flatten into a thin, unappealing (though no less delicious) disk. The middle two samples rested in room-temperature whey and water, respectively. And the sample all the way to the right? The one that looks significantly more round? That's the one that was plunged into ice water, which shocked it and left it as stiff and hard as a handball.
Our favorite mozzarella balls were rested in salted whey for at least 15 minutes and no longer than 40 minutes. Too short a time and they were strangely soft yet chewy and almost rubber bandy. Too long, and they were mushy and slimy. 20 to 30 minutes is the sweet spot, and as soon as your timer goes off you should eat the mozzarella immediately, or at least within a few hours. If you must store or refrigerate it, wrap it tightly in plastic first and use our handy reheating method for optimal results.
And there you have it. Your very own ball of homemade mozzarella cheese. Now you just have to decide what to do with it.
What's that? You already ate it all? Yeah, me too.